At a Glance
- Carrie Underwood wore $349 patent leather loafers on Jimmy Kimmel Live.
- The loafers offer a subtle lift, platform sole, and slip-on convenience.
- Similar styles start at $39, giving shoppers a range of options.
Why it matters: The singer’s choice highlights how loafers can replace heels for elegance and comfort.
Carrie Underwood’s recent appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live showcased a pair of $349 patent leather loafers by Valentina Rangoni. The shoes feature a small platform that adds a subtle lift while keeping the wearer balanced and stable for easy walking. This elegant yet practical look demonstrates that loafers can serve as a polished alternative to stilettos on the red carpet.
The Look That Turned Heads
Underwood’s loafers are made of glossy patent leather, giving them a high-gloss finish that is as eye-catching as traditional heels. The platform sole provides traction, which helps stabilize the feet throughout the performance. The slip-on design means the shoes are quick to put on, making them suitable for busy schedules.
Why Loafers Work for Any Occasion
Loafers are versatile enough to pair with office attire, lunch dates, or more formal outfits. The platform heel offers comfort for long days, and the leather material keeps the shoes dry in wet weather. Because they lack a high heel, they reduce strain on the feet, making them a smart choice for people who spend a lot of time on their feet.
Underwood-Inspired Loafers on the Market
Below is a curated list of loafers that mirror Underwood’s style. Prices range from $39 to $198, and each pair offers a different feature set.
| Brand & Model | Price | Key Feature | Where to Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Franco Sarto Senna Loafer | $125 | Close match to Underwood’s style | Nordstrom |
| Dream Pairs Platform Loafer | $39 (orig. $43) | Padded lining, platform heel | Amazon |
| Quince Lug Sole Loafer | $98 | 100 % genuine leather, lug sole | Quince |
| Bandolino Lindio Loafer | $43 (orig. $79) | Elegant bow detail | Amazon |
| LifeStride London Loafer | $48 (orig. $70) | Plush footbed | Zappos |
| Franco Sarto Carolyn Low Loafer | $99 (orig. $115) | Dressy tassels | Amazon |
| LifeStride London3 Loafer | $80 | Non-slip sole | Kohl’s |
| Quince Italian Leather Horsebit Loafer | $84 | Low heel, horsebit detail | Quince |
| Coach Sculpted C Loafer | $175 | No break-in period | Nordstrom |
| Everlane Leather Day Driver Loafer | $198 | Collapsible back | Everlane |
Detailed Look at Each Option
Dream Pairs Platform Loafer – These loafers come with a padded lining and a platform heel that provides comfort and polish. A shopper noted the heel is “very easy to walk in.” The brown lining offers a refined contrast to the black exterior.
Quince Lug Sole Loafer – Made with 100 % genuine leather, the lug sole keeps feet dry in rain. The inner lining adds extra padding and arch support. Reviews mention that even “avid sneaker” wearers are adding these to their carts.
Bandolino Lindio Loafer – Features an elegant bow and a patent finish, offering a stylish alternative to traditional loafers.
LifeStride London Loafer – Equipped with a plush footbed, these loafers provide all-day comfort.
Franco Sarto Carolyn Low Loafer – Includes dressy tassels and a low heel for a subtle lift.
LifeStride London3 Loafer – Offers a non-slip sole, enhancing stability.
Quince Italian Leather Horsebit Loafer – Combines a low heel with a horsebit detail for a classic look.
Coach Sculpted C Loafer – Designed to be worn without a break-in period, making them ready for immediate use.
Everlane Leather Day Driver Loafer – Features a collapsible back for easy storage and a sleek design.
Key Takeaways
- Carrie Underwood’s choice of patent leather loafers demonstrates how loafers can replace heels for elegance and comfort.
- The loafers’ platform sole and slip-on design offer stability and quick wearability.
- A wide range of under-$200 loafers are available, each with distinct features such as padded footbeds, lug soles, or horsebit details.
- Loafers are suitable for various occasions, from office work to red-carpet events.

By offering both style and practicality, Underwood’s loafers encourage a shift toward footwear that prioritizes comfort without sacrificing polish.

