> At a Glance
> – Kristin Cavallari says her stepmom Nicole King vowed to leave if she filmed season 2 of Laguna Beach
> – Dennis Cavallari reportedly replied, “Then get the f— out”
> – King later told News Of Los Angeles the claims “do not reflect the truth”
> – Why it matters: The rift highlights the real family fallout behind early reality-TV fame
Kristin Cavallari has revealed that her decision to return for the second season of Laguna Beach sparked a domestic showdown that nearly split her father’s household.
The Casting Packet That Started It All
Cavallari, now 39, recalled detailing her dislike for her stepmom in her MTV casting paperwork. She noted that Nicole King was “closer to my age than she was my dad” and admitted she harshly judged the relationship at the time.
During a January 6 episode of her Let’s Be Honest podcast, Cavallari alleged that King snatched the unfinished packet from her hands in high school. After reading the unflattering comments, King developed what Cavallari calls a lasting “hate for MTV” and “complete disdain” for the production.
Ultimatum and Fallout
When MTV green-lit a sophomore season centered on Cavallari, tensions boiled over:
- King warned she would move out if filming continued
- Dennis Cavallari allegedly responded with “Then get the f— out”
- Kristin claims the couple’s ensuing fight was “really nasty” and unfolded in front of her
King declined to elaborate when contacted, telling News Of Los Angeles, “I honestly do not have anything to say. What was said does not reflect the truth. I care about my stepdaughter and wish her the best.”
Dennis Cavallari did not respond to requests for comment.
Estrangement and Aftermath
Cavallari has been estranged from her father for years, a decision she previously called “the best” she ever made. She told News Of Los Angeles last June that cutting contact at age 35 lifted a significant emotional weight and that she hasn’t missed the relationship.
Key Takeaways
- Cavallari’s casting materials criticizing her stepmom seeded long-term resentment
- The stepmom’s ultimatum became a flashpoint for her parents’ marriage
- Kristin’s memories differ sharply from King’s brief public statement
- The family rift persisted well beyond the show’s 2005-2006 run
The revelation underscores how early reality television could amplify existing family tensions, leaving off-camera casualties in its wake.
