At a Glance
- Emily Bute, a special-education teacher, plans to homeschool any future children she may have.
- She cites research on small, individualized learning and the strain of large public classrooms.
- Bute remains in public school, developing a homeschooling program as a side project.
- Why it matters: The video sparked a national debate on the strengths and limits of public education.
Emily Bute, a special-education teacher in a public school system, announced on TikTok that she intends to homeschool any children she might have in the future. The clip, which quickly went viral, prompted discussion about the current state of public schools and the growing interest in homeschooling.
Why Bute is Turning to Homeschooling
Bute explained that her decision comes from both her classroom experience and educational research.
> “My interest in homeschooling comes from both my experience as a special education teacher and what educational research shows about how children learn best,” she told News Of Los Angeles. “I want to be clear that I deeply respect public education and the educators working within it – this perspective is personal, not a criticism of my school, district or colleagues.”
She highlighted three research-based principles that she believes benefit students:
- Small learning environments
- Individualized instruction
- Strong, consistent adult relationships
Despite this evidence, Bute noted that classrooms are increasingly large and teachers are tasked with meeting a wide range of academic, behavioral, and emotional needs with limited time and resources.
> “Research consistently shows that students benefit from small learning environments, individualized instruction and strong, consistent relationships with adults,” Bute continued. “Despite this research, classrooms are increasingly large, and teachers are being asked to meet a wide range of academic, behavioral and emotional needs with limited time and resources.”
Systemic Challenges in Public Schools
Bute pointed to staffing shortages across the county as a key factor. Many teachers are required to teach subjects outside their formal training.
> “This isn’t a reflection of teachers’ dedication – it’s a systemic challenge. But it can impact instructional consistency, especially for our younger learners,” she explained. “Learning also isn’t one-size-fits-all. Children develop at different rates and thrive when instruction can be flexible and responsive.”
She also criticized the emphasis on standardized testing, pacing guides, screen time, and curriculum mandates that often limit hands-on, experiential learning.
> “For me, homeschooling represents the opportunity to slow things down, tailor learning to a child’s needs, and prioritize curiosity, movement, outdoor exploration and real-world experiences alongside strong academics,” Bute added.
Other Options and Real-World Constraints
Bute clarified that she is not dismissing private or Montessori schools. She noted that homeschooling may not be accessible or realistic for every family.
> “Not all parents have the time, resources or confidence to take on full-time learning, and that’s completely valid,” she said. “For me personally, my plan is to homeschool, but I also recognize that there may be seasons where having the support of a school community makes sense for some families.”
She added that Montessori aligns closely with her values but ultimately believes families should decide which educational path fits them best.
Staying in the Public System
Although Bute is planning for homeschooling, she remains in the public school system for the time being.
> “I love teaching, I value the relationships I build with my students and families, and I believe there’s important work to be done from within the system,” she explained. “At the same time, I’m someone who thinks long-term.”
She is currently developing her own homeschooling program, describing it as a “passion project” rather than a means to exit the public system immediately.
Online Reaction
The TikTok video reached a wide audience, and Bute received a mix of feedback. She described the response as overwhelmingly thoughtful.
> “The response has been mixed, but overwhelmingly thoughtful,” she said. “I’ve received messages from parents, teachers and even people without kids who appreciated the nuance of the conversation. Of course, the internet comes with strong opinions, but I’ve tried to view the experience as a reminder of how deeply people care about education.”
A Call for Empathy and Dialogue
Bute emphasized that education should not become a polarizing issue. She hopes her video encourages empathy and open conversation.
> “Public school teachers, homeschool families, private schools – we’re all trying to do what we each believe is best for children,” she said. “I hope this moment encourages more empathy, curiosity and open dialogue rather than division.”
She concluded with a reminder that collaboration benefits children.
> “At the end of the day, kids benefit most when adults are willing to listen, reflect and work together.”
Takeaways
- A seasoned special-education teacher is planning to homeschool future children.
- She cites research on individualized, small-group learning as a key driver.
- Staffing shortages and large classroom sizes are systemic challenges she highlights.
- Bute remains in public school, developing a homeschooling program as a side project.
- Her TikTok video sparked a national conversation about the future of education.
Final Thoughts
Bute’s decision reflects a broader trend of educators re-examining the public school model. While she respects the profession and remains active in it, her experience underscores the growing desire for more flexible, child-centered learning environments.
—
